Stanton Popewiny pleaded not guilty to murder, two counts of conspiracy to commit murder and one count of witness tampering yesterday in Superior Court.
Authorities accused the 23-year-old of bludgeoning his grandfather to death in the latter’s Cedar Grove home, and later attempting to hire a fellow prisoner to kill his wife and a detective assigned to the case.
According to the defendant’s attorney, Miles Feinstein, the prosecution has not offered to negotiate a potential plea bargain.
"If there is any room for negotiations, we will have a discussion with the state," he told the court.
In January, police found Eugene Hrabarchuck – an elderly retired physician living in Cedar Grove - dead at his Woodmere Avenue home, the victim of what a coroner described as "multiple blunt force trauma."
Popewiny – living with his grandfather at the time - was the one who called police about Hrabarchuck’s death, authorities said. Upon arrival, investigators cast doubt upon Popewiny’s claim that his grandfather hit his head after falling down, and arrested him later that day.
The prosecution is considering the possibility that the murder resulted from an inheritance dispute.
The evidence against Popewiny is "overwhelming," Assistant Prosecutor Dawn Simonetti has previously said.
This includes blood splatters on the wall of the bedroom that are inconsistent with Popewiny’s story, and a DNA sample which prosecutors claim indicates that he tried to wash blood from his clothes after the murder.
Prosecutors also requested samples of Popewiny’s handwriting at a hearing in February. When the Times asked Simonetti if the samples were connected to an attempt to alter Hrabarchuck’s will, the assistant prosecutor replied "maybe."
At yesterday’s arraignment, the prosecution also mentioned that they have DVDs containing statements from Popewiny’s wife and an inmate at Essex County Jail.
Prosecutors have said that Popewiny’s wife, Wesley Carr – who has filed for divorce in Pennsylvania, was a witness to "several things that happened that day."
For example, the prosecution said that Carr led police investigators to the potential murder weapon - a handgun found at the Cedar Grove home - which may have been used to bludgeon Hrabarchuck to death. When he learned this at a January bail hearing, Popewiny fainted in court.
In May, Popewiny was additionally charged with attempting to pay a fellow inmate to kill his wife and one of the original investigating police officers.
Popewiny is being held at the Essex County Jail on $1 million bail. As of today, he has spent 194 days in jail awaiting trial.
The prosecution has characterized Popewiny as an "extreme flight risk," and has claimed that he has threatened members of his family in the past.
Popewiny’s parents, through attorneys, have countered that he is "understanding, helpful, loving and kind," and that he’s been involved in community services such as an AIDS walkathon. He is a 2006 graduate of the Global College program at Long Island University.
Popewiny had no criminal record prior his January arrest, according to statements made by the defense and Essex County Superior Court Judge Donald Volkert. According to his attorneys, Popewiny was unemployed at the time of the incident.
The murder was Cedar Grove’s first in 13 years.